That first, nearly forgotten Crispie Creme location was at 264 E. Main St. If you want to visit that historic spot, well, you can't...at least not safely. You see, the building at 264 E. Main St. was at the end of Bridge Street. The dead end. Another interesting fact that many people living here may not know is that Bridge St. once ended at Main St. There was no "North" or "South." Mainly still a residential thoroughfare, it was not yet the shopping and wheeler-dealing mecca it is today. Traveling south on Bridge St. from the Scioto River, to go any farther south than Main St., one had little choice but to turn right and then make another left onto Hickory, Mulberry or Paint St., the latter being the main route through the southern terminus of the city limits.
The postwar national prosperity that allowed for the development of the interstate highway system, also sparked a boom of expansion and development for the city of Chillicothe. The period between 1951-1954 saw the construction of three new grade schools: Tiffin, Worthington, and Mt. Logan; the demolition of the long-obsolete Eastern School (where Speedway, Executive Inn, and McDonald's stand today); the widening of U.S. 23 south; and the expansion of Bridge St. The construction of the atomic plant at Portsmouth around the same time was the impetus for much of this development. Extending Bridge St. to meet up with the improved 23 South would allow for a straighter shot between the new plant and the state capital in Columbus (via Ohio's first capital), and would allow easier access to the new Tiffin Elementary and the existing Mead and Chilpaco plants as a bonus.
Naturally, extending Bridge Street from Main to 23 meant razing everything in its path. Besides relocating families from their homes on adjacent streets, it meant relocating the occupants of several buildings which had stood along E. Main St. for decades. In 1953, when Crispie Creme came to Chillicothe, its neighbors included, going eastward, Orland Ratcliff Motors, Herlihy Moving & Storage, and the aptly named eatery, Bridge End Lunch. Few photos survive of the "dead end" section of Main St., but one grainy photo, taken on a rainy, blustery looking day circa 1951 shows how it used to be.
The story of Chillicothe's first Crispie Creme starts with the Ohio House Hotel, operated by one Eugene O'Callaghan, a prominent member of Chillicothe's sizable Irish-American population, in the early part of the 19th century. A photo of the Ohio House, taken in 1876, shows a basic two-story structure of light brick, with shuttered windows and two entryways, one presumably to the separate "taproom" that was typical of 19th century hotels. The facade differs considerably from what is shown in that evocative photo from the mid-20th century. In approximately 1894, O'Callaghan died, and his family sold the hotel. The buyer was Henry Hydell, a grocer who had been in the business a decade, beginning at the age of 25 when he took over the grocery of Philip Seward at the corner of Water and Hickory Sts.
In the early 1880s, two prominent businessmen, John H. Putnam and Reinhard Wissler (the latter a member of the Wissler Brewery family), purchased land along different halves of the east side of Bridge St. starting at Main, and began building houses and business structures in the area. Putnam constructed a large store at the Main and Bridge, as well as a number of two story brick homes. Wissler, in particular, was enamored of French architecture and his structures were three-story edifices with mansard roofs. One in particular, at the northeast corner of Bridge and Second Sts., a combined store room and residence not too dissimilar to Putnam's building at Main and Bridge, figures into our story at two different points in history.
The occupant of Wissler's commercial-residential structure at Bridge and Second was John Higley, a relative of Wissler by marriage, who lived with his wife and two children in the upstairs apartment, and ran a grocery in the downstairs store. In 1888, Higley sold his stake in the store to Mr. Hydell, who moved his base of operations from Water and Hickory St. to Bridge and Second, and also lived in the apartment vacated by the Higleys. It was in this second location that he became the first grocer in Chillicothe to include an in-house meat department, adding a new level of convenience to his customers. He also operated his own slaughterhouse east of town. Five years later came his move to the former Ohio House. Hydell converted it from a hotel to two large storerooms and a spacious upstairs apartment. This may also be the time period in which the building was remodeled into its later appearance.
Henry Hydell's innovations, as well as his longevity in the E. Main St. location, earned him the title of "the dean of Chillicothe grocers." In September, 1936, Scioto Gazette publisher E.S. Wenis "cheerfully" inducted Hydell Grocery into the paper's 50 Year Club, "as an institution of quality, stability, and service to the public." During his tenure on E. Main St., Hydell's family grew to three sons and two daughters. Sons Clarence F. and Francis Hydell were assisting in daily operation of the store by the 1930s. In August, 1939, Henry Hydell retired, and Clarence took over as proprietor. His first executive decision was to remodel the store, moving the meat department into the grocery section, and rent out the storeroom at 266 E. Main St.
The former Hydell meat department was briefly occupied by the Cycle Shop which moved from N. Walnut St. in 1941. In May, 1943, John D. Herlihy Sr., founder of Herlihy Moving & Storage, who had occupied 268 and 270 E. Main St., divested himself of a related tire sales business, and moved his company offices into the space, where it remained until the buildings were demolished. In November, 1945, Bridge End Lunch opened in the previous Herlihy office at 268 E. Main (which was an A&P Grocery store in the mid-1920s, in direct competition to Hydell's), where it remained until the end of 1952. A little over a year later, "the dean of Chillicothe grocers," Henry Hydell, passed away at the age of 85.
Then, in November, 1947, it was announced abruptly that delivery service by Hydell's Grocery would be discontinued, and on December 2, 1947, the first of several ads ran advertising a 20% discount on all grocery stock, as well as a sale on modern grocery equipment. There was no formal announcement that the store would be closing, nor have I found any reason for Hydell's Grocery going out of business. Then in early January, 1948, C&J Electric Shop ran ads saying "We Are Now Open In Our NEW LOCATION At 264 E. Main St." with no further apparent fanfare. C&J Electric Shop was there until October 1951, when Model Dry Cleaners opened their third location in the spot.
In early 1953, Crispie Creme finally enters the picture, opening somewhere around March, when Chillicothe Telephone Co. installed a new line in their name at 264 E. Main St. An article from April 16, 1953, states that the city Planning Commission had approved the construction of their sign over the sidewalk at that address. Otherwise, the soon-to-be-legendary shop seems to have opened to no apparent fanfare. Could it be because Chillicothe already had the similarly named Dixie Cream Donut Shop, which opened in 1947 and was currently in the old fire station on N. Mulberry St.? :-) Crispie Creme's first year in Chillicothe indeed seems to have been low-key with one exception.
On December 30, 1953, Clarence Hydell, who still owned the property at 264-66 E. Main St., ran an ad for an "Auction Sale Of Household Goods" to be held on January 2. The announcement began "As the state is taking my building for highway purposes..." not just a little bitterly. A small blurb in "Amelia Hydell's Column" of December 23 had quietly announced that "Crispy Cream" had been removed by Herlihy (somewhat ironically) from its current address to High and Water Sts. (across from St. Peter's Church). In January, 1954, the state highway department began running legal notices in the Gazette, soliciting bids for the demolition of a long list of properties that had been acquired by the state, including the former Hydell Grocery. In February, it was announced that local contractor Harold Corkwell had made the winning $45 bid on the property. The former A&P/Herlihy/Bridge End property with its attached structures went to a contractor from The Plains for $150.50, while the winning bid on Herlihy's garage at 270 E. Main was $10.
By springtime, all traces of the buildings were gone, and the construction of S. Bridge St./U.S. 23 was in full swing. Herlihy Moving & Storage relocated their main operations to N. Walnut St. Model Dry Cleaners maintained their previous locations. C&J Electric was now on W. Second St. Of all the businesses that occupied 264-270 E. Main St. in the first half of the 1950s, C&J Electric (on W. Main St. today) and Herlihy (who relocated for good to Marietta Rd. in 1970) are still going strong. Traffic whizzes along the stretch of Bridge St. that didn't even exist 65 years ago, few motorists aware of the history that was wiped out by Atomic Age progress.
As for Crispie Creme, there were a few rough patches along the road to legendary status. In March of 1954, the shop was granted a one-year permit to remain in business at the High and Water location, termed a hardship case as being a relatively young business forced to relocate after less than a year. In October 1957, it was reported that the shop had overstayed its permit by two years, and the city Board Of Appeals was compelled to ask them to vacate the address ASAP. Owner James Renison announced his intention to plead for an extension, having been unable to find another location. The Board obviously relented as Crispie Creme remained at High and Water into the early 1960s. Thus it was to everyone's chagrin when, in the early morning hours of May 6, 1961, a semi-truck from Hennis Freight Lines barrelled through the front of the shop after colliding with a convertible at the intersection, destroying a display case and a donut glazer, and causing considerable damage to the building. The shop was up and running, on a limited basis, by the following week.
After several years of legal pressures, the Renison family built a thoroughly modern, state-of-the-art new location of their own, which opened in the spring of 1965, and thrives to this day. It's one of my favorite places on earth, personally speaking. In a final bit of historical irony, the current Crispie Creme Donut Shop, which first occupied the former Hydell Grocery, is at the northeast corner of Bridge and Second Sts., built on the site of Henry's previous store.
(Below are views of the approximate area of 264-270 E. Main St. in July 1954, and a current view from Google Maps. The two story brick building in these, photos, now occupied by Carlisle Barber Shop, can be seen at far left in the 1951 view near the beginning of the article)
